In Memory Of:

Benjamin M. Schoonover

DHSDOGSHome PageMy Only SonNovember 15th 2006December 26th 2006Deprived PetitionPatrick PickerillArrest WarrantProgress ReportMotion To QuashJanuary 10th 2007January 26th 2007January 30th 2007February 7th 2007February 14th 2007February 27th 2007March 6th 2007March 10th 2007April 17th 2007May 12th 2007Matthew D. HenryMay 24th 2007June 14th 2007July 17th 2007July 29th 2007Howard Hendrick
         Donna Pace          Case Worker D.H.S

 

 

 

August 8 2007

 

 

 

AN OPEN LETTER TO DONNA PACE:

 

 

August 2nd at 1400 hours a Pawnee policeman came to the office of DHS to search me, as I am always searched prior to you allowing me to see my son.  This search is at the request of A. J. Campbell, your supervisor, who made the empty promise last winter that when the weather cleared up we could go outside for visits. 

 

There is no justification for these searches as I am visiting my only son, but, then, I have been searched when I visited other prisoners in other State facilities such as the tiny ‘jail-cell’ setting Elan is taken to for supervised visits. 

 

Months ago I was ordered to not bring his bottle…and then ordered not to bring a banana…it interfered with Elan’s foster parent’s schedule.  That tells one whose interests take priority. 

 

You provided junk food snacks.  Well, if Elan is allowed junk food snacks why isn’t he allowed what I bring: Banana, Blue Bunny Yogurt, Caltrate Chewable 600+D PLUS Minerals for bone…VIACTIV Multi-Vitamin [12 Essential Vitamins plus Calcium] Milk Chocolate Soft Chews. 

 

I all but begged you to let me give my son snacks.  First, you said Elan had just eaten.  Then you brought out of ‘his’ bag a package of sugar coated dry cereal with no protein, what little content they did have was less than 1% of anything…Junk Food.  Elan dug in. 

 

I asked, if he was hungry, why I couldn’t give him the quality food I brought? 

 

“His Doctor doesn’t say he needs it.  If his Doctor said he needed it we would give it to him.”  {His ‘doctor’ also did not say he didn’t need it.}

 

“What is this Doctor’s name?  I’d like to talk to him.”  "I don't know" was your answer.  "You don't know His doctor's name?  You are in charge of my son's life and you don't know his doctor's name?"  "His foster parents do."  "Don't you think I should know who is treating my son?" 

 

I want it in writing from A. J. Campbell that I am not allowed to give my son quality snacks during our visits.   I am allowed to see my only son only one hour per week in your jail-cell setting and it should be quality time.  It should be something special to my son and how special is it if I am not allowed to give my son something he needs (what you said about this phantom ‘doctor’ is stupid bull shit and you know it) that he would enjoy and you are depriving him of that Father/Son partnership/nurturing companionship interaction.   You read my quote of the Oklahoma Supreme Court’s opinion on the nurturing factor of parent/child as paramount under our Federal and State Constitutions you seem to have little/no interest in upholding.  You were in that room, not A. J. Campbell.  It was your decision to deprive my son, not his.  Unless and until I get it in writing from A. J. Campbell that you are acting as a pawn under his orders to deprive my son of nurturing from me the responsibility remains on your shoulders.   Unless and until I get it in writing from Elan’s Doctor, whoever he may be, that he should not be given quality tasty vitamin enriched snacks and quality foods by me, his father, it remains on your shoulders that you are nutritionally abusing my son by insisting on only your  DHS Junk Food snacks. 

 

Your main concern during the entire one hour visit was did I complete any portion of your mandated “Anger Management” course. 

 

Considering what you have just read you should understand that there is no ‘anger’ that needs “management” when it is so calmly/well expressed in this letter.  Does it anger you that I tell not just relatives or neighbors or the county…but the whole world what you do to my son? 

 

You notice I place a digital Panasonic 8-hour audio recorder on the table lest you say I said something I did not say.  Does this anger you?

 

You know now that I publish the photographs of my son on my website to show his expressions that tattle-tail abuse…under your jurisdiction.  Does this anger you?  Are you happy about it? 

 

I told you that at the court house I was threatened by one of your associates that they were going to get someone to infect my computer with a virus…and a week later I got a virus…that cost $200. to clean out.  Coincidence?  I told you I think it is funny.  Did that make you angry? 

 

To get to my website quickest way is to type Mikah McCray in Google.  Will it make you angry for me to fix it so that Donna Pace will work too? 

 

 All I wanted to do was give my son some quality snacks to enrich his physical/mental being while bringing a little enjoyment in our weakly visits.  And if you think he does not need them it is proof that you need some Ex-lax. 

 

Now would be a good time for you to remind me that “We always try to reunite families as quickly as possible.”    

 

You read what I wrote about DHS Director Howard Hendrick and the serious accidental burning of his son Hudson July 4th and how he “waited a day” like you say I did.  Assuming you believe in “Equal Justice Under The Law” do you believe Howard’s son should be put in Foster Care like Elan and Howard charged with Child Abuse under Title 10 because of this accident like I was or do you believe his son should not be put in Foster care pending investigation and my son should not have been confiscated and put in Foster Care for his far less than serious minor injury which would be equal justice under the law?  Or do you simply not believe in “Equal Justice Under The Law”?  Do you believe Howard Hendrick believes in “Equal Justice Under The Law”? Careful how you answer that as it is a known fact that DHS Director Howard Hendrick reads my website.  Does it make you angry that I ask you these questions?  If you have the courage will you put your answers in writing?   

 

There are two colorful billboards in you waiting room:  One large “AND JUSTICE FOR ALL” with the word “equal” omitted.  Are your Howard Hendrik and John Schoonover not to get the same “equal” JUSTICE?  The other billboard, “Preserve Our Future…Become a foster or adoptive parent.”  All well and good for an unwanted child; are there not enough abused unwanted children  to fill your coffers without stealing one who was not abused but loved and wanted and destroying a natural normal Father Son union?  You “preserve” nothing!

 

At the time of this writing my website was paid up to 2017.  At the time this is published on my website it will be paid up to 2027.  My ‘inbox’ gets more responses daily than I have time to answer or post.  Does that make you angry?  If you can think of a better way for me to “manage my anger” that you are foolishly convinced I have than telling the truth and possibly helping other victims of your DHS and frightened parents who will not risk taking their children for medical attention for an accident lest the same fate await them from DHS as you weld to Elan and I then let me know…in writing.  Otherwise, this truth stands:  You advertise for foster parents.  You advertise for adoptions.  That is where the money is.  And when you want perfect babies like my son to sell you scream “child abuse!” to a judge and take them.  Then impose impossible to pay for tasks, called ‘extortion’/‘blackmail’ in Black’s Law Dictionary.  Follow the money.  You are a refined resurrection of Hitler’s Gestapo.  Feared and can never be trusted.  And I cannot blame good parents for not wanting happen to them what you cause by your false charges to happen to my son and I. 

 

A Corrections Officer, not knowing who Elan is, saw a spread of the photographs I had taken and simply asked, “Who abused this child?”  “Mikah McCray” and “Donna Pace” was the answer given.

 

By the way:  The August 2 photographs of the blisters on my son’s left forearm did not show the blisters clearly enough to publish.  What did the “Doctor” say caused them?  Are they abuse or only neglect? The longer you keep my son from me the longer you are abusing him.  Physically, nutritionally, mentally and morally. 

 

We are both being abused by you (DHS) for no reason at all.

 

 

 

                                    *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *

 

 

August 9, 2007

 

1200 HOURS

 

DHS had heretofore always set the date for my supervised visit with my son.  It was an oral agreement with Mikah McCray that I would always call if I was going to be late for any reason or that I could not make the appointment for any reason.  Otherwise, I would be there.  I was dressed and ready to walk out the door to get in the truck.  When it started, and provided there was not a flat tire, which I have not had in well over a year, I would call and let DHS know I would be on time. 

 

Well, I didn’t have to call because Donna Pace called me to advise that because I did not call yesterday, she had cancelled today’s visit.  “Well, what about tomorrow?”  “No, we have you scheduled for Thursdays so we will keep next Thursday…but you need to call me Monday – Wednesday to let me know…” 

 

 I’ve met criminal prisoners on probation/parole with the same restrictions concerning visits with their probation/parole officers. 

 

The majority of good lenient conscientious probation/parole officers try and do help their struggling wards achieve success.  They are an asset to society.  Then there are those that feel all their wards are second class citizens that should have been fed to the lions. 

 

With so many fines and monetary levies difficult or impossible to meet.…or suffer the consequences of the wrath of the ill-directed latter. Some have no way of even possessing a phone.  Or a computer, access to the internet and a website to tell the world….that they are being treated no differently than some, not even guilty of any crime, under the thumbscrew of DHS.     

  

Perhaps I am simply being  presumptuous.  Donna Pace may not simply be flexing her power to ‘show who’s boss.’  Otherwise she would have yielded to my begging to see my son on Friday.  Most likely the ‘surprise cancellation’ is to hide another set of bruises from my camera lens.  

 

If so, they would be healed by the August 16th visit...during which he was very cranky for some unecplained reason...he seemed hot though I was not allowed a thermometer to confirm any fever.    

 

                                                                *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *

 

 

Filed August 10, 2007

 

 

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF PAWNEE COUNTY

STATE OF OKLAHOMA

 

 

State of Oklahoma                                ]

                                                              ]

              Plaintiff                                   ]

                                                              ]   

     Vs.                                                    ]    CF – 2006 - 167

                                                              ]            

John Edward Schoonover                     ]

                                                              ]        

              Defendant                               ]

                                                    

 

MOTION TO QUASH INFORMATION AND DISMISS WITH PREJUDICE

 

 

 

 

Comes now the Defendant John Schoonover appearing with counsel and presents this honorable court with his MOTION TO QUASH, said being presented pro se despite being represented by counsel and fully acknowledging he has been afforded his right to counsel.

 

The Defendant moves this honorable court to quash the information and dismiss with prejudice the charge brought by the State of Oklahoma by and through David K. Robertson, Assistant District Attorney of Pawnee County for reason and authority to wit:

 

 

1.                                          The def was charged by information with the following crime :

Injury to minor child (10-7115)

1

2.                                           The elements are, as listed in the INFORMATION: “wilfully {sic} and maliciously injuring or using unreasonable force upon one Elan Lee Wheeler…”

 

The complaining witness, Mikah McCray, by her own words in her SECOND AMENDED PETITION as composed by Larry D. Stuart, District Attorney for Pawnee County in the matter of Elan Lee Montgomery Wheeler, JD - 06 – 34 states, “The natural father caused the injury to the minor child either through improper handling or carrying said child, or by failure to place said child in a safe place when he left the child unattended which allowed the child to fall and receive the injuries {sic}.”

 

The complaining witness, Mikah McCray, by her own words in her THIRD AMENDED PETITION as composed by Larry D. Stuart, District Attorney for Pawnee County in the matter of Elan Lee Montgomery Wheeler, JD - 06 – 34 states, “The natural father caused the injury to the minor child by failure to place said child in a safe place when he left the child unattended which allowed the child to fall and receive the injuries {sic}.

 

This is not “willfully or maliciously injuring or using unreasonable force.” As defined by title 10-7115 of the Oklahoma Statutes and not by any stretch of the imagination “wilfully and maliciously injuring or using unreasonable force” as claimed in the INFORMATION. 

 

In her “INDIVIDUAL SERVICE PLAN” Mikah McCray, the complaining witness, does not controvert the fact that Elan Lee Schoonover was left unattended for an extremely short period of time, that is to say, “put Elan on the bed between two pillows.  Mr. Schoonover left the room to get a bottle and when he returned, he found Elan on his back on the floor.”

 

2

This act also is not by any stretch of the imagination “willfully or maliciously injuring or using unreasonable force” to a minor child. 

 

3.                                          Should the State ask for a lesser included offense of negligence, this court must find that the evidence does not support the lesser offense being given for the following reasons to wit:

 

“ “child neglect” means the willful or malicious neglect, as defined     by paragraph 3 of subsection B of Section 7102 of this title, of a child under eighteen (18) years of age by another.” 

 

Negligence is acting or failure to act in a manner that a normal person would to prevent injury or harm.

 

This would apply, as an example, should one give matches to a minor child to light and throw on gasoline.  One should reasonably know that gasoline explodes when ignited.  The minor child, having faith in the adult, would reasonably assume the adult was responsible or he would not have been given the matches to light and throw on the gasoline.  Such as the case of DHS Director Howard Hendrick July 4 of this year resulting in serious injury to the minor child, his son Hudson, not yet recovered from the injuries.  However, this act was determined by Attorney General Drew Edmondson to be an accident meriting no action. 

 

Elan Lee Wheeler Montgomery Schoonover was entering the ‘crawling’ stage in life and had not exhibited the ability to roll up and over a pillow at all, much less in a short period of time from being positioned on his back between the two closely placed pillows as barricades the evening of November 14.

3

One could not therefore “reasonably know” that Elan could and would do what he did until Elan proved with his act, that he could and did in fact roll up and over one of the two ‘barricade’ pillows. 

 

It is alleged that the Defendant, after knowing Elan’s arm was injured, “delayed a day allowing the child to suffer needlessly…etc.” 

 

The facts are that Elan, when picked up, stopped crying, took his bottle and went to sleep and slept through the night, rolling over twice on his own, without any indication of any distress.  Elan was alert and smiling when first seen at the Cleveland Hospital and Elan was “alert and smiling” [quote from hospital report] when carried into the OSU Medical Center still showing no signs of any injury and the original radiologist report at OSU even showed no fractures or any other injury.  As the Radiologist, a professional in the medical field could see no injuries; no fractures, then how could it be expected that a layman such as the Defendant could know more than a professional? 

 

Unlike a serious burn that is obvious and obviously needs immediate medical attention to prevent exponential necrosis Elan showed no symptoms of any injury except and only when his right arm was manipulated the morning of November 15.  Photographs of Elan within 10 days of his accident showing him using his right arm in three different positions obviate how minor his injury was.  [attached as exhibit]

 

 

4

When this court, hearing this motion on merits, unbiasedly looks at the facts, it is obvious Mr. Schoonover did not act in a negligent manner. 

 

In this courtroom, November 21, before Judge Mathew D. Henry, Mikah McCray, the complaining witness,  was asked as she testified under oath, if any of the three physicians that she interviewed could state that Elan’s injury was inflicted, to which she replied “No.”  And: Would any of the three physicians that she interviewed state that Elan’s injury was not an accident to which she replied “No.”   Additionally, Dr. Nebergal at Tulsa Regional Medical Center wrote in his report November 15 that this non-displaced fracture “from a fall can not be ruled out.”

 

In closing the Defendant submits that there is no evidence to support any charge of any malicious action and it has been shown there is no negligence by any legal definition and that nothing occurred but an unanticipatable isolated minor ‘normal’ household accident.  

 

The Information must be quashed and the charge dismissed with prejudice.  It is so moved.

 

              Respectfully,

Sigmed

                                           John Schoonover

 

 

Copies to County Attorney’s office

 

 

     Exhibit: Single page of three 4”X6” photographs of Elan Schoonover 10 days after the accident.

 

5

    EXHIBIT  

scan11.png

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

                       *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *     *

 

 

 

 

                                          Back / Next / Home

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 



DHSDOGS | Home Page | My Only Son | November 15th 2006 | December 26th 2006 | Deprived Petition | Patrick Pickerill Attorney | Arrest Warrant | Progress Report | Motion To Quash | January 10th 2007 | January 26th 2007 | January 30th 2007 | February 7th 2007 | February 14th 2007 | February 27th 2007 | March 6th 2007 | March 10th 2007 | April 17th 2007 | May 12th 2007 | Matthew D. Henry Judge | May 24th 2007 | June 14th 2007 | July 17th 2007 | July 29th 2007 | Howard Hendrick Director, D.H.S.